J840 Communicating Social and Environmental Initiatives


Katrina and beyond
July 9, 2009, 10:41 pm
Filed under: J840 Week 4, Society + Media | Tags: , ,

I am horrified by the images and stories of Katrina – still.

Agony Reigns in the Aftermath of Katrina.  National Georgraphic

Agony reigns in the aftermath of Katrina. National Georgraphic

My particular horror, the unforgettable deaths of 35 nursing home residents who were helpless, trapped in their home and victims of rising water.  My connection?  My sister Barbara battled and finally surrendered the use of her legs to a debilitating disease that has changed her physical life.  She resides in an assisted living facility.  Since Katrina I have a deeper interest and knowledge of Barbara’s facility and their evacuation and contingency plans.  I know what will happen should there be an emergency.

New Orleans, then and now.  One year later.  National Geographic

New Orleans, then and now. One year later. National Geographic

The myriad stories of Katrina are real for me because of Barbara, because my childhood neighbor was a physician in New Orleans during the crisis and because the stories are those of real people; victors and victims.

Many of the real stories came to me through advocacy journalism.  I find the stories touching.  I am informed, shocked, committed, changed.

I desire real stories in the media. I want to know of situations that are tragically broken yet ultimately fixable.  I want to know about the survivors, those who are forever changed by circumstances.

I also long for objectivity in journalism.  I define objectivity as an unbiased accounting of the facts.  While it may be easy to get the facts, an unbiased accounting is harder to find.  I serve my need for objectivity by searching multiple sources for multiple points of view.

Are there other ways to develop an unbiased accounting of the facts?

-PegC.


6 Comments so far
Leave a comment

Peg,

One of the ways we, as a society, can develop an unbiased accounting of facts is by encouraging public media, like public radio and TV. Whenever there is an economic or political interest associated with a news entity, there’s a conflict of interest that will almost certainly introduce a bias. Sometimes there’s also the need to introduce stories in real-time to keep up ratings or subscription numbers, which leaves little time to investigate or do any original research.

-Victor V

Comment by victorvi

Victor, I agree with your comments. I’ve been researching bias and found the report I’ve linked below. Note the discussion on bias vs. predilection vs. tone – fascinating. The final paragraph is also interesting – see the comment on how campaign logistics, journalistic norms and pressures from competitive editors may influence the process.

-PegC.

http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=media-bias-presidential-election

Comment by margaretec

Hi, Peg,

I think if advocacy journalism ever had a place it was with Katrina. It was almost too much to comprehend for most of us, and still people in Louisiana and Mississippi, who stayed or went back, struggle to return to their lives. You had such a specific reason to empathize, that brought it right to your door.

It’s been four years now yet there is still so much to do. Do you think these stories now require advocacy journalism to continue to be told? Do you think celebrities who continue to support the area like Brad Pitt, Ellen DeGeneres and Harry Connick, Jr. are the best conduits for the media’s attention?

CarrieS

Comment by carrieshoptaw

Carrie, you raise such an interesting point. Yes, I believe those who feel strongly for a cause are often the most effective voices for the cause. With Katrina there were so many missed opportunities for elected leaders to come together, communicate respectfully and provide solutions as opposed to pointing fingers. What a shame…agree?

-PegC.

Comment by margaretec

Your comment that the people who feel most strongly about a cause are the most likely candidates to advocate for them is so true. Few people look beyond their lives to affect others outside their circle.

I am reminded of Harvey Milk’s advocacy platform early on in the gay rights movement. He said it was important for people to tell others they were gay because people were twice as likely to support gay rights if they know someone who is gay. We are less frightened of things we know about.

Thanks for sharing your sister’s story. It puts a face on what must have been a scary time for both of you.
Holly E.

Comment by hollyee

Holly, I love your observation that we are less frightened when we know/understand something. Makes me think about the work we are doing for our project. The people we are working with put faces and names on the situation.

-PegC.

Comment by Margaretec




Leave a comment
Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>